Top 5 Experienced Amish Builders for Your Wisconsin Project

Amish builders are not regular contractors. They’re craftsmen from faith-based communities whose works show generations of passed-down skill and old-school work ethics.

They’re renowned for their traditional building methods like handcrafted joinery and post-frame construction. Today, homeowners turn to Amish builders for their honest, durable, and highly skilled custom work.

This list offers recommendations on how to hire trustworthy Amish builders and what to expect while working with them. Here are the top five trusted Amish builders in Wisconsin.

Top 5 Amish Builders in Wisconsin

1. Allen Bontrager Carpentry

   Location: Northwestern Wisconsin

   

   Allen Bontrager is a licensed and insured contractor with over 20 years of experience in commercial and residential roofing.

   They offer over 30 colors of metal roofs, which come with a 40-year limited paint warranty. Ranked best in the industry for installation times, their workers have all skills you desire in a roofer.

   From expertise to free estimate offer, it’s little wonder they’re a top choice for Wisconsin homeowners seeking roof replacement.

   Specialty:

   • Steel and shingle roofing
   • Standing seam
   • Gutters
   • Sidings
   • Windows
   • Doors
   • Decks
   • Barndominium builds
   • Garages
   • Sheds
   • Barn

   Service Area:

   Wisconsin (Appleton, Bonduel, Green Bay, Muncie), Indiana, Ohio, and Oklahoma

   Contact:

   715-201-3183

2. Lakeshore Mini Barns

   Location: W5366 Willow Lane, Shawano, WI 54166

   

   Lakeshore Mini Barns is a family-owned and operated constructor of Amish-made storage buildings. They offer over 70 durable stock models and custom options at competitive pricing. They will deliver up to 50 miles free in Wisconsin.

   Specialty:

   • Storage shed
   • Garages
   • Portable barns
   • Mini cabins
   • Mini barn features installation (windows, spray foam insulation, and pressure-treated flooring)
   • 9 customizable basic mini barn styles
   • Free metal siding maintenance
   • LP smart side (wood) in 17 different colors
   • 70 STOCK MODELS
   • Heavy Duty Flooring

   Service Area:
   The entire Wisconsin

   Contact:
   (715) 745-4103

3. Wisconsin Backyard Sheds

   Location: Wautoma, Wisconsin

   

   This Amish Builder emphasizes helping you to build the perfect shed. They have a feature on their website that allows you to put together a 3D model of your perfect shed for them to construct.

   Their standard shed features include:

   • Stamped plates
   • Gable vents
   • Smart finish
   • T Hinges

   They also have custom features like decorative hinges and octagon windows.

   They offer free delivery and setup in Wisconsin. You get a 10-year warranty if your building has a proper gravel base installed.

   Specialty:

   • Sheds
   • Cabins
   • Barns
   • Garages
   • Playhouses

   Service Area:
   Portage and nearby areas

   Contact:
   (920) 293-1123

4. BornConstruction

   Location: Hillsboro, WI

   

   BornConstruction focuses on pole barn building and metal roofing for residential and commercial buildings. They pride themselves on their professionalism and effective communication during jobs.

   They also offer warranties specific to each product. If you give them a call, they will give you a free estimate of your project.

   Specialty:

   • Barn Building
   • Hunting Cabins
   • Sheds
   • Barndominiums
   • Metal roofing

   Service Area:

   Most of Wisconsin and Western Iowa

   Contact:
   (608) 383-3340

5. Mainus Construction

   Location: Waterford, WI

   

   Mainus Construction offers over 30 years of carpentry experience. The company builds using quality materials like LP Smart Panel siding, which is known for its weather protection feature.

   Their precision is reflected in each shed build, from floor installation to structural framing. The team also provides shed moving services for long and short distances.

   Specialty:

   • Gable Roof Sheds
   • Saltbox Sheds
   • Barn Roof Sheds
   • Shed Moving

   Service areas:
   WI and Northern Illinois, Including:

   • Milwaukee County
   • Waukesha County
   • Kenosha County
   • Lake County, IL
   • Rock County
   • Dane County
   • Racine County
   • Winnebago County
   • Fond du Lac County
   • Walworth County
   • Sheboygan County
   • Washington County

   Contact:
   262-806-4389

Why Hire an Amish Builder?

Based on reviews and reputation over the years, Amish builders are known for their efficient work style that helps them create durable and quality structures:

• They employ time-tested techniques like traditional timber framing during construction. They usually learn these skills from a young age and can apply them better than their non-Amish age-grades.
• Their preference for quality materials during construction improves the stability and durability of their structures. For instance, they’ll rather use quality air-dried lumber than engineered wood. The paint you use will also have an effect on the durability of your structure, so you’re better off with a reputable and well-vetted interior painter.
• They build with the aim of functionality rather than aesthetics. Thus, their designs are simple and naturally fit to incorporate concerns like ventilation, drainage, moisture, and leakages. These help to prevent problems like moisture damage and structural issues.

Things to Consider Before Hiring an Amish Builder

When you work with an Amish builder, you must take a break from what you think you know about technology and human interactions. Here’s why:

• Many Amish builders use limited or zero electronic communication tools like phones, emails, or text. You might have to rely on face-to-face communication, letters, a general phone line, or a third-party message receiver.
• They are highly religious and prioritize respect. So, be mindful not to contact them on Sundays or during religious holidays. Don’t utter profanities in front of them.
• Some of them see haggling as disrespectful, so don’t try to sweet-talk them. Just state your terms in plain words.
• Just as you would with any other contractor, ensure that you put into writing your project details, cost, and timelines. As for payment, they favor cash and checks over credit cards.
• As opposed to preconceived notions, Amish builders are not always cheaper. Their preference for quality materials and their exceptional craftsmanship are not cheap.
• Always ask for insurance and licensing before you commission an Amish builder.
• Agree on site cleanup expectations beforehand; do not assume that they will clean up after work.
• Many Amish builders use technology according to their community rules. So, don’t be surprised if you see them make use of power tools on job sites.
• Ensure that they can build according to the modern building code required for the construction type that you desire. Then again, share your home design ideas with them and be sure there is a shared understanding of your wants.
• The quality of work experience always differs from one Amish builder to another. As such, you will need to supervise them to ensure they can achieve your dream home like your self-designed floor plan guide.
• Hiring Amish builders does not reduce the professional building guidance you will require. For instance, you will still need to plan

Amish Builders Cost Expectations in Wisconsin

Based on project type, Wisconsin-based Amish builders can charge the following:

Amish Cabin

Prefabricated Cabins

• A basic shell: From $40,000, depending on size.
• Turnkey (furnished) Cabin: From $60,000, depending on size and finishing level.

Amish Barns

Basic Barn Pole Shell: From $20 per square foot based on barn size and specifications

Amish Homes

• Custom-built Home: From $80 per square foot.
• Modular Homes: From $40,000

Amish Storage Sheds

• Amish-built sheds: From $22 per square foot

FAQs

How to Find Amish Builders

You won’t find most Amish builders online. The most effective way to reach them is to check their communities, rely on word-of-mouth recommendations, or check local directories and business listings. You may also check local farm shops or visit Amish stores to check for adverts.

How Do the Amish Build So Fast?

Amish builders utilize a couple of things that help them build fast. These include:

• Using community members who understand the work blueprint as free labor to speed up building.
• Use of simple designs and preparation of materials and the site before the main workday.
• They are disciplined and have a very strong work ethic.

Are Amish Builders Cheaper?

Amish builders usually have lower overhead costs, which means less expensive labor. However, they make use of quality building materials and exceptional craftsmanship, which can make their overall cost higher than that of non-Amish contractors.